Saturday, 14 March 2009

Ulasan Akademi Fantasia 7 - konsert 1- Full updated

Mmmmmm....first of all, i have to say banyak peserta-peserta yang nyanyi lagu dengan sumbang. Hanya sedikit sahaja yang nyanyi lagu dengan sedap. Most of them hanyalah penyumbang lagu yang sangat bagus. LOL....in fact, banyak peserta yang mengatakan "akan bawa lagu tersebut dengan cara yang tersendiri" tapi lepas jah nyanyi lagu tuh...kalau bukan hancus maybe sumbang atau just like the original version. I was trying to make a comparison with OIAM 3. Lastly, it is clearly perbezaan macam dasar laut dan juga langit biru. Sungguh mengecewakan. Kalau dulu saya merupakan salah seorang peminat AF tapi sekarang, i thought AF is just kutip duit penonton. About the quality??? very little. Most of the students just like orang yang baru jah belajar menyanyi. Moreover, para juri pun bukannya orang yang sangat berpengetahuan dalam bidang nyanyian..cam mana tuh????? very the confused. Konsert yang pertama nie, for me just like pertandingan nyanyian di perikat kampung. Sorry to say. But ada juga dalam 2 atau 3 orang yang memang betul-betul have a great vocal. Anyway...kalau kita tengok para juri pun, diorang lebih banyak komen pasal performance instead of tempo and pitching. Sedangkan banyak betul pelajar yang ada masalah pitching tadi....sungguh mengecewakan. OIAM 3 is thousands times better then AF7. OK lah...let me start one by one from the last student to the first student.

Aril
OK, maybe persembahan yang agak menarik tapi bagi saya, suara beliau agak tawar malam ini. Sungguh mengecewakan! But some people maybe thought he has a unique voice. Just like nubhan, maybe unique tapi kalau x pandai guna suara tuh, still useless. Just like this guy as well. Another good thing is it was a energetic performance. Moreover, it was a pitchy performance and he can't hit the lower notes greatly.
Grade: B-

Rubisa
Since mystarz, i know this girl has a great vocal. In fact, if you look at her tonight she did a great job. The feeling, expression, vocal and energy were there. Very good and she hits the high note greatly as well. Singing this song is not so easy but for me she did it greatly. Very good and keep going girl!!!! the only thing is complain was she did not modify the song with her own style.
Grade: B+

Qauad
OK, yes he has a big vocal. But malang sekali persembahan yang tiada penjiwaan. No feeling at all...i don't know. Lower notes, tak dengar and pitching problem. Even though i just like the song but, he sang is just OK. Nothing special at all. Just like orang persembahkan lagu masa orang kawin. LOL
Grade: C+

Aishah
MMM...such a fun and so nakal performance. Its all rite! lagu also not bad but one more thing lower notes x dengar lah dik!!! The song was easy and she looks so rileks. Still doesn't impress me anyway.
Grade: B-

Obri
This is very karaoke-ish version of this song. He has gesture problem i guess. X de feeling as well. Another bored performance. He hits the high notes just OK but still all rite. Suara also x kena with the song, i thought because the song was boring as well. Pity him coz picked this song.
Grade: C

Rini
Mmmm...what can i say about this girl's performance???? I thought just all rite. But mana plak x-factor yang dicari-cari oleh tenaga pengajar???? nothing. Even a bit saya x nampak. So pity. In fact there was a pitchy problem and also tempo...she like terkejar-kejar that music. For me, overall...just OK but again....nothing special. The vocal also not so powerful.
Grade: C

Adila
she has a big vocal which is not unique anymore. And ada masalah mic at the beginning. Blame to the tehnition. She has problem with the lower notes. Such a happening performance though. A little bit pitch problem.She looks confortable in the stage. Honestly, this the worst version of "dibawa pohon asmara" i ever heard.
Grade:B-

Sidi
Masuk jah, dah sumbang. Oh..i am sorry. The vocal is just all rite and a little bit karaoke for me.In fact, he almost can't reach the high notes. So pity! He looks nervous as well.Moreover, there is no dynamic on his vocal and the rendiation also empty. So bored vocal.
Grade: C

Zizi
Oh...My G. I don't understand most of the parts of the song. The low notes were SUCKS. X dengar. Even though the performance was fun and a little but naughty but vocally, very poor. She looks confortable on the stage though and very good interaction with the audiances. Maybe she has a good vocal but last night's performance her goodness did wasn't there.
Grade: C

Yazid
"Bila kekasih....." the first verse of the song he sang it horribly. I am sorry for his fans but he sang the song very usual. In fact the vocal also very tawar and not intresting at all. Picthing problem as well. Oh..i can't wait he going to finish the song. Very boring and he sang it just banyak flat...
Grade: D

Akim
I thought i saw this guy in OIAM 3. He was singing "i'm yours" by Jason Miraz. He has a very good vocal but why did he choose this song? What a bored song huh? The song seems like an easy song but he sang it a little bit boring and there are some parts picthing problem. The entrance of the song also very "tawar"...huh!!!!! i know he has a good vocal but he picks the wrong song and it made the performance very ketinggalan zaman.The tone is nice though. O ya..another thing..yes..the song very old for him.
Grade: C+

Hafiz
First of all the song was very nice. He picks such a beautiful song. Wow..he has a great vocal. Among the guys, i thought he has the greatest performance. The low notes to high notes i can hear it clearly. The hair must be expensive kan? looks like guy sbestian hehehehe. Overall, i love the performance and for AF's level it was great for 1st concert.
Grade: A-

Claudia
Oh...she really has problem with her low notes. I can hear it clearly. In fact, sometime seems like flat. Oh....another thing, the performance was really bored and so many pitching problem. She sang this song just like kaorake version and sometimes i thought worst then it i guess. Suara also still raw...
Grade: C

Isma
Vocally it was good and the facial expression was good.But at the middle of the song it was alittle bit bored. But why pakain looks so ugly lah. With jeans and that baju???? OMG...very ketinggalan zaman. But vocally i think not so bad. Keep polish it.
Grade: B

My ranking;
1. Hafiz 2. Rubisa 3. Isma 4. Aril 5. Aishah 6. Adila 7. Akim 8. Qauad 9. Akim 10. Zizi 11. Claudia 12. Sidi 13. Rini 14. Yazid (worst)

8 comments:

my name is KARL said...

i've ranked top 5 best vocal & performance in my blog!

btw,

my favs are:
akim, aishah, aril, isma, rubisa, hafiz, claudia (byknyerr...haha))

oiam3... ermm.. i go for tomok & fify

C.Alv.B said...

Andrik sa afundi ko jadi pengkritik di AF8 nanti hehehe..sa pun nda berapa minat AF sudah..too commercial sudah..saya lebih suka tengok American Idol and OIAM.. sorry to say la but..AF more gimik than original talent

Puteri Ezza said...

Yuhuuu bro. Apa khabar? Lama inda pi sini... :)

My Ranking pula (Top 10 jak):
1. Hafiz
2. Aishah
3. Qhaud
4. Rubisa
5. Zizi
6. Isma
7. Sidi
8. Aril
9. Akim
10. Rini

jeremytuah said...

nice review.. i wanted to do my own but mcm x worth it cuz last week concert sucks where all of the contestants sucks and didn't produce any star quality YET.. so tgu la kalu dorang okay sua.. mcm AF hilang seri sua, mcm tngk RTM talent show pla.. huhuh

Andrik McVean said...

good...good....

Anonymous said...

salam,,weh aku nak tanye nih,,cane nak tengok af gne tenet huh,,,malam nih konsert weh,,,nak tengokkkk,,,,,!!!!!

Andrik McVean said...

cam mane nak tengok af online just google it..

ranie said...

saya pilih hafiz juara,kalau tak pasti malu af 7 nanti,banyak yg sumbangkan lagu...ke2 akim byk peningkatan..aishah dan mungkin isma kerna husband,pihak astro ndak 2long promote..lastly aril @ claudia..maybe aril,ada pakej tp mutu suara ke laut,claudia suara semacam dyg nurfaezah...artis swak.
Hafis kalau x juara..af 7 maybe kalah oleh QIAM.

Other stories

Related Posts with Thumbnails