Review OIAM - Top 7- Full review

Oh.......let me say something. I love the guest judge tonight because she gave very nice comments and looks so professional. Not like most of the previous guest jugdes before. They were so not professional. First of all, the overall performance tonight were just all right. In fact, some of them quite bored actually. However, some of them were very entertaining and have a very good vocal control. Oh...whatever! i still like OIAM compared to AF7. Why? because the contestants in OIAM 3 are very creative. O ya...before i start my review, i think fify shouldn't be voted out tonight. Why? because i thought she did quite a great job last week. I love the melody arrangement actually. But??? what to do? she has voted out and we really have no choice. She has to go. Good bye fify!! OK guys, let me start my review regarding their performance (wah..like professional lah..hehehehe).

Esther
To be honest i love her "I DON'T LOVE YOU" version. In fact i have to agree with syafinaz because actually her version is more "tidy" and the melody arrangement was very nice as well. Compared to the original version, it was a bit messy. I thought it was a great job and very creative from her too. Vocally...she did it very well. She sang a rocker song and she modified and sang it very well. But i don't like the dress because she looks like pregenent contestant. Sorry!!! O ya..another thing i like the drama when she drops the "gelang" and the laughing voice. Very dramatic actually. By the way, i am not very familiar with the song it wasn't my "cup of coffee" .
4 stars / 5 stars


Rizu
Well, maybe the judges were right when they said he has a cute personality and also he has a big vocal for a small boy like him. But one thing my comment is sometimes i thought his voice like too much pushed and its sound like memaksa untuk menyanyi. Mmmmm...i have to agree with Paul because the song's melody is very easy and safe one. As a result his last night's performance doesn't show his vocal arrangement and the power. Sadly, i love his "sandaran hati" version.
3.5 stars/ 5 stars

Simon
Actually his performance ended like a photocopy version. It was a little bit bored and it was a very safe performance. In fact, if i not mistaken he seems lowed the keys of the song (maybe i'm wrong...). Just nothing special with his performance actually. Well, i love the song as i am RB's fan. But simon did not deliver it successfully. Pity!
3 stars/ 5 stars

Aweera
Mmmm...only one thing i can say (banyak sebenarnya...tapi benda yang sama jah every week). The band is so grand but he looks and his performance were too small. Vocally...not so good, in fact the last part of the song....he was shouting and panjang plak tuh??? Arghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh (something like that lah.)
3 stars / 5 stars

Amylea
It was a very soft jazz and boringggggggggggggggggggggggggggg lah!!!!! seriously. If i was Paul. I would say like this "I CAN'T WAIT YOU TO FINISH THE PERFORMANCE (style simon AI8)". Yeah...something like that lah. But vocally it was great and undoutable she can sing and i have to give a credit to her regarding to her song. But my opinion, the song is forgatable. There is no strong melody on the song. Sorry...
3.5 stars / 5 stars

Nine
Good...energetic ya???? But because he too concetrate to connect with the audiances he missed the vocal side. What a pity..The vocal seems like too messy and brterabur. Oh....It was a fun though!
3 stars/ 5 stars

Tomok
Mmmm..what a creative performance from him??? oh...i never imagine he can sing and modified that song isn't??? Very creative actually. He reminds me about david cook when he modified lagu mariah carey. Even though, i thought syafinaz version is good but what Tomok did is very unforgatable. He really know how to connect with the audiances and and the judges. As paul said he is intelligent more than he looks. But piching like lari sket lah.
4 stars/ 5 stars

My weekly ranking:
1. Tomok 2. Esther 3. Rizu 4. Amylea 5. Aweera 6. Nine 7. Simon